Skip to main content

'Atiku’s concept of restructuring is understandably vague' - Osinbajo replies his predecessor in an explosive letter




Nigeria's Vice President, Yemi Osinbajo, has replied his predecessor and presidential aspirant, Atiku Abubakar, who criticised his stance on restructuring.

Osinbajo who spoke in the U.S. about restructuring not being Nigeria’s major problem said, “It is about managing resources properly and providing for the people properly, that is what it is all about”.

Atiku Abubakar who is also a former vice president however said Osinbajo got it wrong, “It is a surprise that the Vice President would take such a position and, in particular, fail to appreciate the connection between Nigeria’s defective structure and its underperformance,” he said.

The vice president has now replied Abubakar in a signed letter addressed to the edito of PREMIUM TIMES.

Read the full letter below.
Dear Editor,

Kindly permit me a response to a piece in your publication, titled “Osinbajo got it wrong on Restructuring,” written, we are told, by my illustrious predecessor in office, Alhaji Atiku Abubakar.
First, let me say that I really would have expected Alhaji Abubakar to at least get the full text of my comments before his public refutal of my views. But I understand; we are in that season where everything is seen as fair game! He quoted me as saying that “the problem with our country is not a matter of restructuring… and we must not allow ourselves to be drawn into the argument that our problems stem from some geographic re-structuring”.
Yes, I said so.
As the quote shows, I rejected the notion that geographical restructuring was a solution to our national problems. Geographical restructuring is either taking us back to regional governments or increasing the number of States that make up the Nigerian federation.
As we all may recall, the 2014 National Conference actually recommended the creation of 18 more States. And I argued that, with several States struggling or unable to pay salaries, any further tinkering with our geographical structure would not benefit us.
We should rather ask ourselves why the States are underperforming, revenue and development wise. I gave the example of the Western Region (comprising even more than what is now known as the South West Zone), where, without oil money, and using capitation tax and revenues from agriculture and mining, the government funded free education for over 800,000 pupils in 1955, built several roads, farm settlements, industrial estates, the first TV station in Africa, and the tallest building in Nigeria, while still giving up fifty percent of its earnings from mining and minerals for allocation to the Federal Government and other regions.
I then argued that what we required now was not geographical restructuring but good governance, honest management of public resources, deeper fiscal Federalism, and a clear vision for development.
On the issue of deeper fiscal Federalism or restructuring, I explained how the then Lagos State Government, led by Asiwaju Bola Ahmed Tinubu, decided to fight for greater autonomy of States.
As Attorney-General at the time, it was my duty and privilege to lead the legal team against the then Federal government, in our arguments at the Supreme Court. I am sure that Alhaji Atiku Abubakar would remember these cases on greater autonomy for States that I cite below, as he was Vice President of the Federal Republic of Nigeria at the time.
At the Supreme Court, we won several landmark decisions on restructuring Nigeria through deeper fiscal federalism, some of which our late converts to the concept, now wish to score political points on.
It was our counter-claims alongside those of other littoral States, that first addressed so comprehensively the issue of resource control. We agreed with the oil producing States that they had a right to control their resources. We argued, though unsuccessfully, that the Ports of Lagos were also a resource, which should enable Lagos State, in the worst case, to be paid the derivation percentage for proceeds of its natural resources. Years later, we also filed an action at the Supreme Court arguing that the Value Added Tax, being a consumption tax, should exclusively belong to the States.
 must read: Kidnappers of Edo APC chairman demands N20m ransom
On the issue of who, between the Federal and State governments, should have authority to grant building permits and other development control permits, the Supreme Court, by a slim majority, ruled in our favour. It held that, even with respect to federal land, States had exclusive authority to grant building or other developments control permits.
In 2004, we created 37 new local governments in Lagos State. We believed that we had a Constitutional right to do so and that in any event, a State should have a right to create its own administrative units. Several other States joined us and created theirs.
The Federal government’s response was to seize the funds meant for our local governments, thus strangulating States like Lagos, which had created new local governments. We challenged this at the Supreme Court. The court held that the President had no right under the Constitution to withhold or seize funds meant for the States. The allocations were not a gift of the Federal Government to the States. They were the Constitutional right of the States and local governments.
The court also agreed that States had a Constitutional right to create local governments, pursuant to section 8 of the Constitution, but that the creation remained inchoate until the National Assembly, by resolution, amended the existing list of local governments to capture the newly created LGs.
In response, we created by State Law, Local Council Development Areas (LCDAs), to accommodate the newly created Local Government Councils until such a time as the National Assembly would complete the process. But the Lagos State Government took up the challenge to re-engineer its revenue service, making it autonomous. With innovative management, tax collection in Lagos became more efficient, and tax revenues continued to grow geometrically. Today, the State earns more IGR than 30 States of Nigeria put together!
Further, we contested the attempts of the then Federal Government to create supervisory authority over the Finances of Local Governments by the signing into law of the Monitoring of Revenue Allocation to Local Governments Act, 2005. The Supreme Court also ruled in our favour, striking down many provisions of the law that sought to give the Federal government control over local government funding.
I have been an advocate, both in court and outside, of fiscal Federalism and stronger State Governments. I have argued in favour of State Police, for the simple reason that policing is a local function. You simply cannot effectively police Nigeria from Abuja. Only recently, in my speech at the Anniversary of the Lagos State House of Assembly, I made the point that stronger, more autonomous States would more efficiently eradicate poverty. So I do not believe that geographical restructuring is an answer to Nigeria’s socio economic circumstances. That would only result in greater administrative costs. But there can be no doubt that we need deeper fiscal Federalism and good governance.
Alhaji Atiku’s concept of restructuring is understandably vague, because he seeks to cover every aspect of human existence in that definition. He says it means a “cultural revolution”. Of course, he does not bother to unravel this concept. He says we need a structure that gives everyone an opportunity to work, a private sector driven economy. Yes, I agree. These are critical pillars of our Economic Recovery and Growth Plan (ERGP), including our Ease of Doing Business Programme.
If, however, this is what he describes as restructuring, then it is clear that he has mixed up all the issues of good governance and diversification of the economy with the argument on restructuring.
Good governance involves, inter alia, transparency and prudence in public finance. It involves social justice, investing in the poor, and jobs for young people; which explains our School Feeding Programme, providing a meal a day to over 9 million public school children in 25 States as of today. Our NPower is now employing 500,000 graduates; our TraderMoni that will be giving microcredit to 2 million petty traders; our Conditional Cash Transfers giving monthly grants to over 400,000 of the poorest in Nigeria. The plan is to cover a million households.
Surprisingly, Alhaji Atiku leaves out the elephant in the room – corruption. And how grand corruption, fueled by a rentier economic structure that benefits those who can use political positions or access to either loot the treasury or get favorable concessions to enrich themselves. This was a main part of my presentations the Minnesota Town Hall meeting.

In arguing for good governance, I made the point that our greatest problem was corruption. I pointed out that grand corruption, namely the unbelievable looting of the treasury by simply making huge cash withdrawals in local and foreign currency, was the first travesty that President Buhari stopped.
I showed the OPEC figures from oil revenues since 1990. In four years from 2010 to 2014 the PDP government earned the highest oil revenues in Nigeria’s history, USD381.9billion. By contrast the Buhari Administration has earned USD121 billion from May 2015 to June 2018, less than 1/3 of what Jonathan Administration earned at the same period in that administration’s life. Despite earning so much less, we are still able to invest more in infrastructure than any government in Nigeria’s history. The difference is good governance, and fiscal prudence.
In the final analysis, restructuring in whatever shape or form, will not mean much if our political leaders see public resources as an extension of their bank accounts. This, I believe, is the real issue.

Comments

Popular posts from this blog

"I'm the luckiest man to walk the planet": groom cries as he sees his bride-to-be in her dress for the first time

A groom couldn't control his emotions and he broke down in tears when he saw his bride walking towards him in her wedding dress. Tyrone Armitage, from Melbourne, was marrying his partner of 11 years, Kelly Armitage, just days after receiving the sad news that his father was losing his long battle with cancer. After receiving this tragic news, Tyrone decided that all that mattered was marrying the love of his life and having the people that mattered most around him. On the wedding day, photographer James Day was on ground to capture their big day and he captured quite a lot, one of which has now touched hearts all over the world. The particularly emotional photo shows Tyrone crying, and the back story of a very touching statement he made as tears pooled in his eyes has made it even more touching. James Day said he asked Tyrone what he was thinking at the moment the photo was taken and his reply was that he felt like the "luckiest man to wa...

Mom, 44, who survived breast cancer twice graduates on the same day as her daughter

                                      Tasha Oliver (right) and her daughter Cierra Patterson - A mom has graduated from college with her daughter on the same day - She survived breast cancer twice - They both studied healthcare management It is a happy occasion for a 44-year-old mom to graduate from college on the same day as her daughter. However, it was an even happier occasion when the mom, Tasha Oliver of Georgia, US, made the achievement recently after surviving breast cancer twice. Tasha and her daughter Cierra Patterson both graduated with diplomas in healthcare management from Clayton State University. Her first cancer diagnosis was in 2006 and her second came in 2009, one year after she enrolled for her studies in 2008. In an interview, Tasha's daughter Cierra said: "I think the second time, that was a shocker. You don’t think something like that would happen again a...

Photos: Gov. Ambode attends ''Lagos Means Business'' at Eko Hotel Hotel and Suites

Lagos State Governor, Mr. Akinwunmi Ambode; Chairman, Heirs Holdings, Mr. Tony Elumelu and Founder, First City Monument Bank Group, Otunba Subomi Balogun during the “Lagos Means Busine ss” (a parley with the Governor), at the Eko Hotel and Suites, Victoria Island, on Tuesday, March 6, 2017. Lagos State Governor,  Mr. Akinwunmi Ambode and other important dignitaries, attended the  ''Lagos Means Business'' (a parley with the Governor) which held at Eko Hotel Hotel and Suites on Tuesday. More photos below...  R-L: Lagos State Governor, Mr. Akinwunmi Ambode; his Deputy, Dr. (Mrs) Oluranti Adebule; Chairman, Zenith Bank, Mr. Jim Ovia and Founder, Ruff ‘n’ Tumble Nig. Limited, Mrs, Adenike Ogunlesi during the “Lagos Means Busine ss” (a parley with the Governor), at the Eko Hotel and Suites, Victoria Island, on Tuesday, March 6, 2017.  L-R: Lagos State Governor, Mr. Akinwunmi Ambode, with Founder, First City Monument Bank Group, ...

Gov. Abiodun reinstates teachers sacked by Amosun

The Ogun State Governor, Prince Dapo Abiodun has reinstated the immediate past NLC Vice Chairman in Ogun state and the then state Chairman of the Nigeria Union of Teachers, Oludare Ilekoya and Olusanjo Majekodunmi sacked by Senator Ibikunle Amosun. Abiodun, who announced the reinstatement of the two teachers at MKO Abiola International Stadium, Kuto, Abeokuta during this year’s World Teachers’ Day celebration said the gesture was not only to encourage the teachers in the state, but it was the right thing to do. He equally enjoined teachers and other union leaders to be moderate in their approach in all their agitations from government, saying our labour unions and associations to always show understanding in your agitations as no meaningful results can be achieved in an atmosphere of rancor and discord”. Speaking on the reinstatement of the sacked teachers, Abiodun said, “I wish to reiterate that this administration’s commitment to the principles of equity, fairness, justice, and...

Nigerian guy begs to flog him, use as slave and ready to wash dirty pants of Facebook crush Updated: 7 hours ago

Jessica Ifunanya Nwachukwa has taken to her Facebook account to share an extremely bizzare message she recieved from a Nigerian guy. Smart Ochuka, who is obviously obsessed with his crush, expressed his readiness to serve her as a slave, wash her dirty underwear and do her friends' chores only to be beside her. He even offered to flog him if Jessica wishes as he is absolutely okay with dominant women More photos of Jesicca are below: Up

Nigerians are divided over over Senator Tinubu and Elisha Abbo's clash during his disciplinary hearing

At the first sitting of the committee on Monday July 9th, Senator Elisha Abbo clashed with Senator Oluremi Tinubu when he appeared before the Senate ad-hoc committee investigating his assault on a nursing mother inside a sex toy shop in Abuja on May 11th. Upon his arrival at the senate room where he was to be questioned, 41-year-old Abbo refused to swear an oath and also refused to speak in the presence of journalists. According to him, the matter is in court and anything he says in front of the press, can be used against him. Apparently angered by his stance, Tinubu said “Distinguished, you just joined us. We have a procedure and we are also under law. You don’t come in here and dictate to us what should be done,” Mrs Tinubu told Abbo, a Peoples Democratic Party (PDP) member. You are on the other side now. You don’t tell us what to do…because we can suspend you,” she added. Replying in anger, Abbo said  “I will not sit here an...

President Buhari’s re-election chances are as tall as El-Rufai - Reno Omokri

It is no longer news that President Buhari has declared his interest to seek a second term in office, much to the secret chagrin of his side kick, Malam Nasir El-Rufai, who, though he feigns delight at the President’s decision, is secretly disappointed. His over ambition is very well known in power circles and he was hoping that the President would stand down and instead pick him as his proxy. But that is not my focus for this piece. My focus is the reason the President gave for wanting to be re-elected President. A statement released by the Presidency, “the President said he was responding to the clamour by Nigerians to re-contest in 2019.” Notice the language. The President is not running because he has a good record of achievement (he does not). He is not running because he has plans to implement (again, he does not). He is also not running because he has unfinished projects to complete. President Buhari instead is running because of the “clamour by Nigerians”...

''My wife is fine'' - Timi Dakolo denies reports that Busola has been traumatized since her rape story was published

Timi Dakolo took to his Instagram comment section to shut down reports that his wife, Busola, has been traumatised and weeping since the interview she granted accusing COZA pastor, Biodun Fatoyinbo, of rape, was published on Friday June 28th  According to Timi, Busola is fine

These sculptures depicting the slave trade are so heartbreaking

Man's injustice against man. More photos below.

Warning men - 3 costly mistakes in the bedroom that makes women cheat, lead to broken marriages and poor sexual performance

This is a sponsored post... There are 3 mistakes that most men make in the bedroom; that makes them unable to satisfy their woman in bed, have poor sexual performance and often time makes their wife cheat on them. My name is Mrs. Esther, and truth is from my years of research and experience, I have found that these 3 things are what cause complaints from most women. Before I tell you about them, first, you must know that about 2 years ago… I was also complaining about   these 3 things my husband did in the bedroom, that made our sex life boring , and almost destroyed our marriage because he was unable to perform in bed. Let me tell you about them… Poor Hygiene   – Women complain about a man having dirty and unclean hands more than anything else. They are disgusted by the thought of dirty hands touching them both on their body, breast or private parts. Do yourself a favour and get a hand sanitizer so you can get soft, tender hands. Little or no foreplay...